6. Increasingly mobile devices are an aid to the gathering and reporting of information, both by professional journalists and “citizen journalists”. Outline the advantages and disadvantages of this sort of news gathering. How might it impact on journalistic practices and news values and ethics?
Initial thought about this topic;
Find it interesting to write about as I have been a bit in touch with it, in regards to the cultural jamming and making "false" reports on websites. NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT MOBILE DEVICES I WILL BE TALKING ABOUT - MOBILE, LAPTOP...ETC. PLUS, WHAT IS A CITIZEN JOURNALIST? NEED DEFINITIONS! FIND OUT IS YOU ARE GOING TO FOCUS ON TRADITIONAL NEWS - NEWSPAPER ETC OR MEDIA NEWS. last paragraphs on impact in news story. CHOOSE A FEW KEY ADVANTAGE/DISADVANTAGES and write how they work for and against - back up with research, "this guy says it is good and why- this guy says it is bad and why". This whole thing is my research so far! Job well done, I must admit!
Initial thought about this topic;
Find it interesting to write about as I have been a bit in touch with it, in regards to the cultural jamming and making "false" reports on websites. NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT MOBILE DEVICES I WILL BE TALKING ABOUT - MOBILE, LAPTOP...ETC. PLUS, WHAT IS A CITIZEN JOURNALIST? NEED DEFINITIONS! FIND OUT IS YOU ARE GOING TO FOCUS ON TRADITIONAL NEWS - NEWSPAPER ETC OR MEDIA NEWS. last paragraphs on impact in news story. CHOOSE A FEW KEY ADVANTAGE/DISADVANTAGES and write how they work for and against - back up with research, "this guy says it is good and why- this guy says it is bad and why". This whole thing is my research so far! Job well done, I must admit!
Another trend in the media sphere has been the growth in the role of the 'media citizen'. This is part of the blurring of roles between consumer and producer that the internet provides. Media outlets everywhere now openly call on readers, viewers and listeners to contribute words, images and footage. Media Giant CNN has the easy address of 'ireport.com', through which viewers can contribute material. This provides important supplementary updates to CNN's 24-hour-a-day news service. For example, during a spate of major tornadoes in Oklahoma in the United States, sensational footage was supplied by a citizen reporter, allowing the network to broadcast this almost as the twister occurred (CNN news, 23 May 2008). - Johnston J., & Zawawi C., Public Relations, Theory and Practice 3rd Edition, p. 240-241.
Citizen journalist:
Journalist and media commentator Mark Glaser gives a very good definition of citizen journalism on the Public Broadcasting Service website MediaShift. To paraphrase, he describes the citizen journalist as a person, with no real journalism training, who uses modern technology to create news stories and then distributes them over the internet. In order to understand the power that the average Joe now has to make news we need to think about the tools of the journalist. In order to produce news you need two things:
(1) a method of recording and producing information (either in a text, video, image or audio format), and
(2) a method of getting that info to the public
Citizen journalist is not out to cover something, but to share it.
Citizen journalist:
Journalist and media commentator Mark Glaser gives a very good definition of citizen journalism on the Public Broadcasting Service website MediaShift. To paraphrase, he describes the citizen journalist as a person, with no real journalism training, who uses modern technology to create news stories and then distributes them over the internet. In order to understand the power that the average Joe now has to make news we need to think about the tools of the journalist. In order to produce news you need two things:
(1) a method of recording and producing information (either in a text, video, image or audio format), and
(2) a method of getting that info to the public
Citizen journalist is not out to cover something, but to share it.
Advantages
In fact, when big events happen, such as the July 7 London bombings, much of the footage which the media outlets have is from citizen journalists because, by their very nature, they are first on the scene. Most media outlets, including the BBC, now ask for people to send in footage and photos of events or small write ups of anything they may have seen. http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
News stations, or whoever that receives the citizen journalists findings are more than thankful to citizen journalists as many people would not know what the smoke was looked like close to the Twin Tower buildings on 9/11/2001, what the tunnels looked like after the London bombings or what damage that was caused from the tsunami in Thailand. This is because news stations or CNN (whoever) cannot send their own TV crew or journalists to the locations because of the amount of danger they are putting their employees in.
Disadvantages
Advantages & Disadvantages that work together and against each other
- The availability of news and current streaming of it as it is happening;
In fact, when big events happen, such as the July 7 London bombings, much of the footage which the media outlets have is from citizen journalists because, by their very nature, they are first on the scene. Most media outlets, including the BBC, now ask for people to send in footage and photos of events or small write ups of anything they may have seen. http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
News stations, or whoever that receives the citizen journalists findings are more than thankful to citizen journalists as many people would not know what the smoke was looked like close to the Twin Tower buildings on 9/11/2001, what the tunnels looked like after the London bombings or what damage that was caused from the tsunami in Thailand. This is because news stations or CNN (whoever) cannot send their own TV crew or journalists to the locations because of the amount of danger they are putting their employees in.
- News as a partnership
It could be said that today news provided from both citizen journalists and professional journalists collaborate on what will be distributed to the public.
- Touched on stories that are taboo, often written/ spoken/ filmed with human interest
This can be seen as journalists often want to highlight a subject, but are prohibited by either the ethical framework or simply what they are allowed to report on. The citizen journalist can shed some light on the subject with a personal point of view (something professional journalists are prohibited by).
- Shared views on the internet
This could work for or against, as too many views create a clash, meanwhile personal views also add the human interest factor and novelist.
Disadvantages
- The credibility of the news
This could be said as the news could be hard to verify, the citizen journalist has not followed the ethical rules a professional journalist follows and the citizen journalist is not a professional writer, therefore the content might seem poorly written or hard to understand. Citizen journalists often write as they talk, which can affect their credibility's negatively.
This could also be looked at in a positive way as the back up from photos or footage from the citizen journalist can verify their story and be directly distributed to the public.
This type of citizen journalism includes some comment as well – often far more outspoken than that which you would find on an open page in a newspaper. This can be good because there are fewer reservations but also bad because there is so much more room for them to offend and spout ill informed views. http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
Advantages & Disadvantages that work together and against each other
- The credibility of the news
This could be said as the news could be hard to verify, the citizen journalist has not followed the ethical rules a professional journalist follows and the citizen journalist is not a professional writer, therefore the content might seem poorly written or hard to understand. Citizen journalists often write as they talk, which can affect their credibility's negatively.
This could also be looked at in a positive way as the back up from photos or footage from the citizen journalist can verify their story and be directly distributed to the public.
This type of citizen journalism includes some comment as well – often far more outspoken than that which you would find on an open page in a newspaper. This can be good because there are fewer reservations but also bad because there is so much more room for them to offend and spout ill informed views. http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
- The availability of news and current streaming of it as it is happening;
For example, during a spate of major tornadoes in Oklahoma in the United States, sensational footage was supplied by a citizen reporter on ireport.com, allowing the network to broadcast this almost as the twister occurred (CNN news, 23 May 2008). When discussing CNN and their ireport.com website, they do include a warning of how none of the news you are about to read or see has been looked at or authorized by CNN, except the ones with a CNN stamp on it. Therefore the reader is already warned that not everything is necessarily true.
In fact, when big events happen, such as the July 7 London bombings, much of the footage which the media outlets have is from citizen journalists because, by their very nature, they are first on the scene. Most media outlets, including the BBC, now ask for people to send in footage and photos of events or small write ups of anything they may have seen. http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
Resources;
http://snurb.info/node/1360
http://snurb.info/taxonomy/term/1
http://www.labnol.org/internet/blogging/will-citizen-journalists-replace-the-professional-journalist/1611/ (use this link!!!)
http://www.actnow.com.au/Opinion/The_Rise_of_the_Citizen_Journalist.aspx
http://ireport.cnn.com/
http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
Scholarly sources:
Johnston J., & Zawawi C., Public Relations, Theory and Practice 3rd Edition, p. 240-241.
http://www.nieman.harvard.edu/reportsitem.aspx?id=100542
http://opendepot.org/134/1/thurman_forums.pdf
http://www.labnol.org/internet/blogging/will-citizen-journalists-replace-the-professional-journalist/1611/ (use this link!!!)
http://www.actnow.com.au/Opinion/The_Rise_of_the_Citizen_Journalist.aspx
http://ireport.cnn.com/
http://www.responsiblecitizen.co.uk/citizenship-journalism.html
Scholarly sources:
Johnston J., & Zawawi C., Public Relations, Theory and Practice 3rd Edition, p. 240-241.
http://www.nieman.harvard.edu/reportsitem.aspx?id=100542
http://opendepot.org/134/1/thurman_forums.pdf









